Supreme Court ruling on Kasab brings partial closure

Author : C.Uday Bhaskar

The Mumbai attacks of Nov 26, 2008 (often referred to as India's 26/11) reached partial closure on Wednesday with the decision by the Supreme Court to uphold the conviction and death sentence awarded to the lone surviving gunman, Mohammad Ajmal Kasab, in May 2010 for his role in the carnage that took 166 lives. Apart from Indian citizens who bore the brunt of the attack, there were as many as 25 other nations whose citizens were either killed or injured. Jews were particularly targeted.

The enormity of 26/11 and the manner in which Kasab and his team killed scores of civilians was captured live on TV footage and the telephone communication with the ‘handlers' in Pakistan gave the entire event a macabre quality where the real and reel telescoped into each other. At that time in late 2008, emotions ran high in India and angry, collective revenge had to be kept at bay so that justice could be rendered to the victims and their families who suffered grievous loss.

India sets considerable import to what is called the ‘due process of the law' and despite the enormous trial court backlog, the Kasab case moved fairly swiftly by Indian standards and the case reached the Supreme Court. To that extent it may be inferred, that at a purely individual level, some degree of justice has been rendered with the decision of the Supreme Court, which has opined that the accused was accorded a fair trial and the gravity of the crime -- "participated in waging war against the country" -- warranted the death penalty.

However, Kasab is unlikely to go to the gallows in a hurry for in all likelihood, the August 29 decision will be sent for appeal and a review and if rejected, the case could finally be referred to the President of India for mercy. What is germane is that one of the surviving perpetrators of a major terror attack could be prosecuted through the law of the land and that ‘due process' was respected. The degree of solace that this kind of justice will provide to the families of the victims is moot and some foreign nationals may still seek different forms of redress and compensation through their own legal provisions.

The larger and more complex issue of 26/11 is the linkage with the Pakistani security apex, for as an individual; Kasab was a mere foot soldier -- albeit lethal in killing unarmed innocents. The Supreme Court judgement noted inter alia: "The most clinching evidence regarding conspiracy comes from the recordings of intercepted telephone calls between the terrorists and their co-conspirators and collaborators sitting in a foreign land that, in light of the overall facts and circumstances of the case, can only be Pakistan". The linkage between the perpetrators of 26/11 with the Lashkar-e-Taiba and the support that this group has traditionally received from the Rawalpindi GHQ is part of a well-known narrative about the patterns of cross-border terror in the region. This has now been reiterated by the highest court in India.

It may be recalled that in the immediate aftermath of 26/11, the first reaction of the Pakistani security establishment was to deny Kasab's nationality as a Pakistani and it took an intrepid Pakistani journalist to expose the truth. In the intervening years, there has been more innovative opacity than sincere intent on the part of the Pakistani security establishment to prosecute the high-level handlers of the Kasab team -- and this is predictable.

The 26/11 carnage and the reluctance of the Pakistan government to enable speedy prosecution on their side will come up for discussion in the Tehran meeting between Indian PM Manmohan Singh and the Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari, where they are expected to meet on the sidelines of the NAM Summit.

But the reality is that the Pakistani security establishment had deliberately invested in terror groups as part of the ‘strategic depth' doctrine more than 20 years ago and this policy has neither been reviewed nor altered. Lest this assertion be seen as partisan, it may be recalled that soon after the terror attack (Aug 16) on the Kamra airbase near Islamabad, a noted Pakistani security analyst made an insightful and courageous observation.

Ayesha Siddiqa averred that despite General Kayani asserting that the war on terror is Pakistan's own war -- there was no policy shift towards groups espousing the ideology of terror. She added: "Groups such as the Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT), Jaish-e-Mohammad, Sipah-e-Sahaba and Lashkar-e-Jhangvi, which have safe havens in the country (Pakistan), continue to thrive."

In a non-linear manner, the Kasab-Kayani eco-system continues to be nurtured in Pakistan even as it is denied to Islamabad's external interlocutors, which is why 26/11 will only have partial closure.


*C. Uday Bhaskar is the former Director of the New Delhi-based National Maritime Foundation. The views expressed are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the Indian Navy or National Maritime Foundation. This article first appeared in the Reuters on August 29, 2012.
redirect why married men cheat on their wives looking for affair
cheaters caught men who have affairs
kr vijaya sex stories open teen sex stories
i dream my husband cheated on me woman affair why men have affairs
discount card pharmacy site free grocery coupons
side effects from ciprofloxacin ciprofloxacin antibiotic side effects ciprofloxacin 500mg tablets
walgreen printable coupon walgreens coupons online
dapoxetine tadalafil 60mg
temovate sumatriptan pill inderal pill
viagra coupon coupon viagra
viagra free sample coupons open free discount prescription cards
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
cialis prescription price click coupons for cialis 5mg
2015 cialis coupon prescription drugs discount cards coupons for prescriptions
new prescription coupon new prescription coupon
cialis coupons 2015 open cialis sample coupon
cialis discount coupons cialis sample coupon prescription coupon card
viagra szedése viagra ár viagra 100mg
naproxen fk click naproxen migraine
cialis gel cialis forum
niacin click niacin band
vaniqa comprar vaniqa chile vaniqa
metformin 850 mg click metformin
citalopram hydrobromide 20mg citalopram hydrobromide usp monograph citalopram hydrobromide side effects
cyklokapron cyklokapron dosering
zantac reflux zantac
tenormin efectos secundarios tenormin classification
esomeprazole sandoz side effects esomeprazole actavis capsules esomeprazole rbx nexium
transfer prescription coupon new prescription coupon
verapamil wikipedia verapamil wikipedia verapamil horton
coupons and discounts forms of abortion discount coupon
having an abortion abortion pill stories price of an abortion pill
amoxicillin endikasyonlar amoxicillin 500 mg amoxicillin 500 mg
vermox vermox vermox sirup
cialis online coupon coupons for cialis free cialis samples coupon
costs of abortion pill pro abortion
vermox 100mg vermox doziranje
abortion pill cons early abortion pill options abortion price
duphaston i ovulacija duphaston duphaston tablete za odgodu menstruacije
abortion pill laws medical abortion pill
duphaston tablete kako se piju duphaston 10 mg duphaston
abortion pill pros and cons abortion pill clinics in md
printable coupons for cialis coupon for cialis coupons for prescriptions
costs of abortion pill price of abortion pill information about abortion pill
prescription drug coupons prescription discount coupons prescription coupon
buy abortion pill when can you get an abortion pill abortion pill recovery
metoprololsuccinat hexal 50 mg metoprololsuccinat bivirkninger metoprolol pro medicin
vermox doziranje vermox suspenzija vermox suspenzija
vermox suspenzija vermox doziranje vermox doziranje
alternatives to abortion pill abortion pill cons
how much do abortion pill cost in clinic abortion pill alternatives to abortion pill
cost of abortion pill the abortion pill cost articles on abortion pill
addiyar newspaper addyi addyi
nootropil review nootropil review nootropil danmark
acetazolamide spc acetazolamide 250 mg tablets
cialis sample coupon transfer prescription coupon cialis sample coupon
amoxicillin-rnp amoxicillin 1000 mg
best coupons websites andreinfo online coupons codes
illegal abortion stories where to have an abortion reasons against abortion
naltrexone side effects a comprehensive view naltrexone 1.5 mg
ldn and ulcerative colitis vivitrol
vivitrol shot side effects what is vivitrol can u drink on vivitrol
naltrexone pellet side effects click naltrexone uk
low dose naloxone read alcohol blocker
how long does revia stay in your system site where to buy naltrexone
naltexone naltrexone fda vivtrol shot
how long does naltrexone take to work click shot to stop drinking

Back To Top