• :
  • :

                                                                          
       

CHINA'S RECALL OF 1911 XINHAI REVOLUTION: IMPLICATIONS FOR INDIA



Author : C.Uday Bhaskar


A hundred years may be a temporal punctuation for an ancient civilisation like China or India but the commemoration of the 1911 Xinhai revolution that overthrew the Qing dynasty in China may be deemed an event of tectonic proportion for Asia, in particular the world by extension.

Two millennia of imperial rule had come to an end - and Asia's first republic was born. The 1911 Revolution began as an armed uprising on the evening of October 10, 1911, when Xiong Bingjun, a soldier in the New Army engineering battalion fired the first shot in Wuhan that signalled the start of the 1911 Revolution. Thus ended one of the most enduring autocratic regimes in the world, established by Emperor Qinshihuang in 221 BC. Successive emperors held the Chinese people in thrall for centuries and the last imperial dynasty was the Qing Dynasty, which came to power in 1644 AD and which the 1911 Revolution displaced. However ownership of the 1911 revolution is bitterly contested between Beijing, capital of the People's Republic of China and Taipei that represents the Republic of China. In Beijing, President Hu Jintao extolled the 1911 Revolution and described it as "a thoroughly modern, national and democratic revolution." He also recalled the contribution of Sun Yat-sen, the leader of the revolution, as "a great national hero, a great patriot and a great leader of the Chinese democratic revolution."

President Hu noted that the 1911 Revolution had shook the world and ushered in unprecedented social changes in China. While the last assertion is accurate - that China rocked the global boat and has ushered in extraordinary socio-economic changes in a milieu that that had kept its people in servitude or deprivation of different type - Beijing's claims on 1911 and the reference to 'democracy' are untenable. The Chinese Communist Party had little to do with 1911 and its credentials to being democratic are invalid. As the parallel celebrations in Taiwan have demonstrated, it was the Sun Yat-sen and Chiang-kaishek team that laid the foundations of the Republic of China and the transition from imperial rule to democracy - or a semblance of it that Asia's deeply entrenched feudal DNA has differently nurtured.

The Republic of China itself under the Chinese Nationalist Party was hardly the model democracy that 1911 had envisioned. Mainland China and ROC adopted different paths after the vicissitudes of World War-II, culminating in the triumph of Mao's Long March in 1949. Ever since, Taipei and PRC have staked their exclusive claim to both Chinese nationalism and normative political identity. A hundred years later, the two Chinas have evolved on different trajectories and clearly Beijing has impressive numbers on its side and the global endorsement of its brand. Diminutive Taipei is the more vibrant democracy - after the lifting of martial law in 1987 - and remains the intractable 'other' that Beijing has not been able to subsume or ignore.

Whether Beijing is celebrating 1911 and the birth of the democratic impulse in Asia, or 1949 - wherein the Communist Party morphed into the new imperial dynasty is moot and this is the point of relevance for India.

Anniversaries have their own import in the collective psyche of a society and states recall and embellish them in the pursuit of the abiding objective of monopolising power.

For India, this October will mark the run up to the 50th anniversary of the humiliating defeat of the 1962 border war with China. It is fortuitous that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh addressed the combined military commanders on Tuesday - October 11 - and while there was no explicit reference to China in the PM's remarks as available in the public domain - the narrative and self-image that is being burnished in Beijing as part of the 1911 centennial commemoration is of abiding relevance to the Indian national security and military apex.

PRC has a self-image and historical national narrative that is predicated on selective exclusion of facts and history and carefully nurtured collective amnesia. Thus in PRC's recall of the last 100 years since 1911 - the excesses of Mao's Cultural Revolution and the Great Leap Forward when millions died or were displaced finds no mention. Tiananmen of 1989, which had a Gandhian democratic texture to it has been totally obliterated in the main exhibition at the UN in New York and this is the characteristic of PRC and by extension the PLA that Delhi will have to decipher and manage.

Like Taiwan being an intractable 'other' - democratic India that is now also exuding signs of sustained economic growth is an existential challenge to the idea of China conceived by Mao in 1949. Managing this entity which oscillates from benign panda to belligerent dragon is the challenge for the Indian political apex. This can be better done if India exudes both tangible military capacity and the political determination to maintain a non-provocative but equitable posture in its bi-lateral dealings with Beijing. This can only happen if the current dissonance within the Indian fauj and its policy neutral, subaltern institutional status receives the undivided and unmediated attention of the PM.

(The writer is a former director of the Institute of Defence Studies & Analysis. This article first appeared in the Economic Times on October 12, 2011).
vacuum abortion early termination pregnancy pill why have an abortion
abortion at 15 weeks abortion clinics in el paso tx vacuum abortion procedure
symptoms of an std in women read std on tongue pictures
married men who have affairs maryaltmansblog.com.nobullsoftware.com women who cheat on their husbands
why do women cheat on husbands cheat husband why husbands cheat
free sex stories non-consensual adult interracial stories wife adult stories
reason why husband cheat keelingconsulting.com wives that cheat
mature sex stories solveit.openjive.com erotic stories sex stories
free printable grocery coupons link rx drug coupon
walgreens prints coupon codes click walgreens photo prints coupon
walgreens code photo go walgreens photo promo code 2015
dapoxetine mgdking.com tadalafil 60mg
prescription drug discount cards viagra discounts coupons prescription discounts cards
viagra coupon 2016 floridafriendlyplants.com viagra free coupon
cialis dosage information go cialis for women dosage
acheter viagra generique pas cher acheter viagra generique pas cher acheter viagra generique pas cher
cheap online viagra effects of viagra buy viagra internet
2015 cialis coupon prescription transfer coupon coupons for prescriptions
cialis gel blog.devparam.com cialis cijena u bih
levitra spc levitra koupit levitra original
kamagra jaysmith.us kamagra jelly
gino-canesten creme read gino-canesten corrimento rosado
cialis walgreen coupon open cheap cialis
transfer prescription coupon datum-digital.com new prescription coupon
oxcarbazepine mylan click oxcarbazepin
coupons websites for groceries promo code grocery coupon site
surgical abortion read pro abortion
research paper on abortion houston abortion clinic facts against abortion
seroquel 25 seroquel xr seroquel compendium
ondansetron orally totspub.com ondansetron 8mg
amoxicillin endikasyonlar abloomaccessories.com amoxicillin dermani haqqinda
voltaren krem nedir lasertech.com voltaren krem fiyat
discount coupon for cialis prescription discount coupon prescription drugs coupons
cialis free coupon farsettiarte.it cialis trial coupon
cialis coupon lilly coupons for cialis 2016 discount coupon for cialis
imodium dosage realtycollective.com imodium instants
valtrex alkohol valtrex 500 valtrex 1000mg
omeprazole enceinte omeprazole omeprazole vidal
prescriptions coupons prescriptions coupons cialis discounts coupons
prescription drug coupons discount prescription coupons printable coupons for cialis
coupons for cialis coupon cialis cialis savings and coupons
vermox cena vermox vermox spc
duphaston tablete kako se piju duphaston 10 mg duphaston
free cialis coupons supermaxsat.com cialis savings and coupons
how much does an abortion pill cost abortion pill articles different types of abortion pill
abortion pill information abortion pill methods teen abortion pill
facts on abortion pill how does abortion pill work cost of abortion pill
abortion pill achi-kochi.com free abortion pill
free printable cialis coupons aegdr.org lilly cialis coupon
vermox doziranje vermox bez recepta vermox suspenzija
feldene blog.zycon.com feldene
prescription transfer coupon coupons prescriptions cialis coupons free
vermox tablete nuspojave vermox sirup cijena vermox 100mg
duphaston cijena bez recepta duphaston forum duphaston i ovulacija
free cialis samples coupon prescription drugs discount cards prescription coupon
naltrexone injection for opiate addiction link revia dosage
naltrexone pellet side effects open naltrexone uk
what is vivitrol medication link naltrexone pharmacology
vivitrol wiki site naltrexone classification
how long does revia stay in your system go where to buy naltrexone
naltrexone 3mg charamin.com how to make low dose naltrexone
naltrexone cocaine lasertech.com naltrexone used for