Re-Imagining India's Borders

Author : Shyam Saran

It is time we made our border regions full stakeholders in the country's development

The conventional view of national territorial boundaries is that these are, or ought to be, strong and durable fences, safeguarding the country from hostile external forces. Passage across these fences must, therefore, be through tightly controlled, carefully regulated and narrow gateways. This is an outdated notion in the modern world and the time has come for us to begin to look at our borders as “connectors” or “transmission belts”, which bring us closer to our neighbours in a mutually beneficial embrace rather than as impenetrable walls behind which we insulate ourselves. This is the first mindset change we need to foster.

As corollary to this, we must also stop treating our border areas as belonging to the periphery or serving as “buffer zones”, preventing ingress into the heartland. We must rid ourselves of this “outpost” mentality and acknowledge that our border states and regions are as much part of our national territory as are the so-called heartland states. The notion that these areas should be left underdeveloped and remote, as is reflected in the outdated colonial instrument of inner-line permits, must be abandoned. An empire ruled by a foreign power may have had some logic in creating buffer zones. This, however, has no place in an independent, sovereign country, where citizens living in any part of the national territory are equally entitled to the fruits of development and economic integration.

If borders are connectors then border states become important platforms for mutual interaction with our neighbours. They can serve as bridges linking India with its neighbours. Such interaction could become the catalyst for economic development of border regions both in India and in neighbouring countries.

Pursuing such interaction requires convenient and hassle-free cross-border movement and, therefore, efficient cross-border connectivity. We have neglected the development of our land border areas and our outlying islands precisely because of an outdated mindset. This is beginning to change but far too slowly. In the Indian subcontinent, cross-border connectivity today is far less than in pre-partition India. The vision of an economically integrated south Asia leveraging its obvious complementarities cannot become reality without efficient transport, communication and, now, digital connectivity.

We need to follow certain principles in undertaking cross-border infrastructure projects.

One, while putting in place such projects, it is important that this goes in parallel with the establishment of appropriate backward linkages. The progress in cross-border infrastructure must never outpace the all-round integration of our frontier regions with the rest of the country. If this happens, it will be a recipe for alienation in these sensitive frontier regions, endangering our security. One sees this phenomenon in northern Myanmar, which is today more closely integrated with southern China than the rest of the country.

Two, we must abandon the concept of border trade and replace it with trade through border points. Border trade in an agreed list of designated local commodities, limited to a designated zone on either side of the border, is thoroughly outdated at most places. Several points on the India-Myanmar or India-Nepal borders are well connected with the rest of the country on either side. Trade in local items is far outstripped in volume and value by a great variety of goods which are officially “contraband”. On my visits to the Tamu-Moreh border point on the India-Myanmar border, I have witnessed how truckloads of Chinese goods, all contraband, find their way into our north-east and beyond. The only way to address this is to open border trade points to regular most-favoured nation trade. It should not really matter what goods are coming in from which country of origin as long as requisite duties are paid. The government earns revenue while minimising the opportunities for corruption.

This does not mean that in truly remote areas we should stop the holding of traditional border “haats” or local trade fairs. However, we should make certain that these areas do not become channels for illegal trade.

The criminalisation of much of our border trade, the involvement of local mafias in such trade and the corruption this engenders among precisely those of our authorities that are assigned the job of looking after our sensitive borders, are threatening our national security much more than the opening up of our borders to regular trade and economic activities. The lesson to be learnt is that the economic development and prosperity of our border regions will greatly enhance, not diminish, our national security.

It is time we re-imagined our country’s borders and made our border regions full stakeholders in India’s development. This is also a prerequisite for realising our vision of a south Asia, where borders have ceased to matter and there is a free flow of goods, peoples and ideas across our frontiers.

(This article first appeared in the Business Standard on June 24, 2011)
click here husbands who cheat read here
early abortion options vacuum aspiration procedure
mens symptoms of chlamydia where to get std test free std
cheat on my boyfriend click should i cheat on my boyfriend
my husband and i both cheated i cheated on my husband and never told him
reason why husband cheat beautiful women cheat women want men
online affair women who want to cheat how many women cheat on their husbands
how to tell if wife has cheated wife cheat story my wife cheated
women who cheat on husbands site my wife cheated
when married men cheat why women cheat in relationships why people cheat in marriage
coupons rite aid site pharmacy coupons 2015
walgreens photo coupon code free prints rx coupons printable walgreens coupon online
coupon rx walgreens photo print coupons pharmacy exam coupon code
walgreens online coupons link online pharmacy coupon code
viagra trial coupon pharmacy coupon rx coupon code
renova tube finasteride 5mg revia pill
celecoxib 200mg thyroxine 50mcg
coupon for free viagra free prescription cards discount drug discount coupons
viagra coupon card viagra coupon card 2016 viagra coupon
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
cialis prescription price click coupons for cialis 5mg
augmentin eureka augmentin et alcool
metformin 850 mg metformin
naproxen 500 go naproxen
gino-canesten creme go gino-canesten corrimento rosado
cialis walgreen coupon cialis 20mg cheap cialis
motilium et grossesse motilium eureka
coupons for drugs transfer prescription coupon
trental online buy go trental cijena
norfloxacin uses norfloxacin alcohol side effects norfloxacin uses 400mg
coupon code coupon codes popular coupon sites
loette 21 comprimidos loette diario
lilly cialis coupons prescription coupon
dilation and curettage procedure pill to terminate pregnancy
prescriptions coupons coupons for cialis 2016 cialis discounts coupons
medications for pregnancy how soon can you terminate a pregnancy how many weeks pregnant abortion
coupon cialis discount prescription coupons cialis online coupon
acetazolamide migraine acetazolamide sivuvaikutukset acetazolamide symptoms
amoxicillin amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat amoxicillin 500 mg
abortion pill pros and cons abortion pill is wrong abortion pill clinics in md
how much does an abortion pill cost abortion pill articles different types of abortion pill
printable coupons for cialis coupon for cialis coupons for prescriptions
abortion pill information abortion pill methods teen abortion pill
duphaston tablete duphaston forum
cialis tadalafil cialis pris cialis wiki
metoprololsuccinat hexal 50 mg metoprololsuccinat hexal 50 mg metoprolol pro medicin
second trimester abortion abortion pill clinics in houston definition of abortion pill
types of abortion pill price of an abortion pill
cost of abortion pill medical abortion cost articles on abortion pill
metoprolol pro medicin metoprolol metoprolol medicin
flagyl flagyl precio
best coupons websites make coupons online for free online coupons codes
amoxicillin amoxicillin 500 mg amoxicilline
illegal abortion stories abortions facts reasons against abortion
naltrexone injection cost read naltrexone 50 mg
will naltrexone show on a drug test click vivitrol alcohol treatment
where can i buy naltrexone naltrexone generic low dose naloxone
naltrexone dosage for alcoholism how to get naltrexone out of your system what is naltrexone 50mg
ldn naltrexone read alcohol blocker shot
naltrexone generic name injection for alcohol craving
vivitrol injection cost click naltrexone clinic
how long does revia stay in your system go where to buy naltrexone
naltrexone information low dose naloxone use of naltrexone
revia drug starting naltrexone
lidocain nebenwirkungen lidocain synthesis lidocain zahnmedizin

Back To Top