Author : C.Uday Bhaskar

Both books are valuable additions to the existing scholarship on nuclear weapons and the fine-print of deterrence

Chitrapu Uday Bhaskar

Nuclear weapons hang over humanity like the sword of Damocles. Catastrophic destruction is held back by the slender thread of the nuclear weapon states' non-decision to ‘use' this apocalyptic capability again — since the devastation of August 1945.

Nuclear weapons are back in global focus for more reasons than one. The United States President, Barack Obama, has infused the much-needed political traction to the global disarmament effort and his April 2009 Prague speech is a case in point. But time will tell if there is substance and sincerity of purpose in what he said. Concurrently, there are deep anxieties about the non-state entity acquiring nuclear weapons or fissile material and the revisionist manner in which a rogue regime may behave. The current turbulence in Pakistan only heightens these concerns.

T.V. Paul, a distinguished academic (of Indian origin) at the McGill University, Canada, has made a valuable contribution to exploring the historical experience of the non-use of nuclear weapons and the challenges now faced globally. His book on the subject was published first in 2009 by Stanford University and the current volume is its South Asian edition. Distinction

Paul builds on Thomas Schelling's 1960s formulation of the “tradition of non-use” of nuclear weapons and makes a nuanced distinction between ‘tradition' and ‘taboo' in a very rewarding and illuminating semantic detour. The central argument advanced is that the tradition of non-use has been shaped by two factors. One, the sheer destruction caused by the use of a nuclear weapon; and second, post the advent of the hydrogen bomb, “the negative reputational effects its use would generate...”

Appropriately textured, the argument draws upon other theoretical propositions, from both the rationalistic/materialistic and normative/ideational schools. But as the author says, his effort is “to offer a richer analysis and not to create a grand theory but an intermediate theory, in order to explain the puzzle of nuclear non-use.” The analysis is comprehensive and, predictably, more focussed on the U.S. experience under President Truman to President Clinton. Israel, India, and Pakistan are addressed as part of the second generation nuclear states and their ‘use' of the nuclear weapon is briefly delineated. Pakistan will remain a complex puzzle for the academic and the ambiguity that accompanies its WMD posture may merit a more detailed study. Is deterrence the main purpose of the Pakistani nuclear capability, as it ought to be normatively speaking, or is it to bolster “its continued resort to asymmetric warfare to wrest territory from Indian control?”

This is where a more holistic interpretation of what constitutes ‘use', when it comes to nuclear weapons, would have embellished the rich and insightful analysis. The existential dimension of nuclear weapons and how this ominous reality impacts the behaviour of the ‘other' in any nuclear dyad — the current U.S.-Pakistan tussle for example — is yet another strand that warrants some interrogation. It is arguable that Pakistan's contribution to the ‘use' of nuclear weapons is NWET — nuclear weapon enabled terrorism — and here both the U.S. and China have specific relevance. This subject may have to await another major work by the author.

The second book under review,Complex Deterrence,deals with some very complex issues apropos nuclear deterrence in a lucid and easy-to-comprehend manner and should be of interest to the specialist and the lay person having an interest in such arcane, albeit life and death matters. Edited jointly by three scholars of repute, the 12 chapters explore deterrence conceptually and in relation to non-state actors, smaller powers, and the major powers. Deterrence

In a must-read introduction to deterrenceper se, Paul posits that complex deterrence can be defined as “an ambiguous deterrence relationship, which is caused by fluid structural elements of the international system to the extent that the nature and type of actors, their power relationships, and their motives become unclear, making it difficult to mount and signal credible deterrence threats in accordance with the established precepts of deterrence theory.” The contributors to this substantial volume are eclectic and include men of eminence such as Robert Jervis and Janice Gross Stein.

Both books are valuable additions to the existing scholarship on nuclear weapons and the fine-print of deterrence, as it is opaquely interpreted and uneasily practised in this century, with the certitude of the bloody 20th century as the foundation. These are subjects that warrant objective and informed deliberations by both state apex and civil society representatives.

The Baruch plan (1946), the Rajiv Gandhi U.N. proposal (1988), and the Obama Prague speech (2009) need to be threaded and taken forward step by step, till the world attains that utopian global zero, and we must all hope fervently that deterrence — whether complex or otherwise — works, in this interminable interregnum.

This review has appeared in the Book Review section of THE HINDU on 21 Jun 2011.
redirect link online
abortion at 14 weeks how to terminate early pregnancy at home
all women cheat married cheaters percent of women that cheat
cheat on my boyfriend click should i cheat on my boyfriend
reason why husband cheat beautiful women cheat women want men
why do men cheat on their wife dating for married men
married men who have affairs link women cheat because
husband cheat read what to do when husband cheats
letter to husband who cheated why women cheat on men
interactive adult stories boys suck boys dick sex stories
walgreens photo coupon code free prints click walgreens coupon online
discount card for prescription drugs discount prescription drug card viagra coupon pfizer
walgreens code photo walgreens print coupon walgreens photo promo code 2015
dapoxetine tadalafil 60mg
doxycycline valacyclovir 1g
best pharmacy discount card site new prescription coupon
canada drug pharmacy coupon drug coupons
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
cheap online viagra effects of viagra buy viagra internet
free cialis coupon 2016 cialis coupon free
naproxen fk naproxen migraine
augmentin et grossesse augmentin augmentin générique
motilium et grossesse go motilium
aldactone compendium read aldactone avis
imodium smelt click imodium smelt
zantac reflux zantac
tenormin efectos secundarios tenormin classification
free discount prescription card cialis coupon lilly
abortion pill over the counter abortion atlanta
abortion video go abortion techniques
cialis coupons and discounts cialis coupon lilly new prescription coupons
amoxicillin dermani haqqinda amoxicillin 500 mg
amoxicillin 500 mg amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat amoxicillin
loette vademecum loette diario loette 21 comprimidos
when is it too late to get an abortion pill information on abortion pill against abortion pill
clomid testosterone clomid proviron
vermox dosering vermox 100 mg
abortion pill procedures abortion pill debate when is it too late to get an abortion pill
nortriptylin wirkung nortriptylin adhs
clomid testosterone clomid testosterone
abortion pill centers average cost of an abortion pill
lamisil para que sirve lamisil para que sirve
amoxicillin al 1000 amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat amoxicillin nedir
how much do abortion pill cost abortion pill stories where to get an abortion pill
vermox suspenzija vermox tablete nuspojave vermox doziranje
alternatives to abortion pill abortion pill cons
vermox tablete nuspojave vermox doziranje vermox tablete nuspojave
addyi wikipedia addyi
abortion pill services third trimester abortion pill how much is the abortion pill
aspiration abortion the abortion pill
abortion pill debate misoprostol abortion
acetazolamide spc acetazolamide 250 mg tablets acetazolamide 250 mg tablets
vermox tablete nuspojave vermox cijena vermox 100mg
voltaren ampul voltaren krem nedir
amoxicillin 1000 mg amoxicillin al 1000 amoxicillin al 1000
amoxicillin amoxicillin 1000 mg amoxicilline
revia drug go naltrexone wikipedia
naltrexone withdrawal symptoms neltrexon
what is ldn go naloxone implant
naltrexone dosage for alcoholism how to get naltrexone out of your system what is naltrexone 50mg
what is low dose naltrexone used for click what is vivitrol
vivitrol injection cost naltrexone clinic
neltrexon naltrexone pharmacy alcoholism
naltrexone adverse effects site once a month shot for opiate addiction
vivitrol for alcoholism go vivatrol

Back To Top