• :
  • :

                                                                          
       

BEYOND THE PAKISTANI INITIATIVES IN RELEASING MV SUEZ






Author : Nitin Rai

Other than the fact that six of its 22 sailors were Indian nationals, the MV Suez, an Egyptian-owned, Panamanian-flagged ship, was more about Pakistan.

It was captained by a Pakistani national and was on a voyage from Karachi to the Eritrean port of Massawa in July-August 2010, when it was hijacked by Somalian pirates in the Internationally Recommended Transit Corridor (IRTC), off the Horn of Africa. It sent distress signals to the EU Naval Force (EU NAVFORCE) patrolling the region but was seized before naval helicopters could arrive. The ship, cargo and crew have been held for ransom since then.

Its release was also, on the face of it, a largely Pakistani affair. Negotiations between the ship’s Egyptian owners and the pirates were deadlocked until February 2011, when Ansar Burney, a prominent Pakistani human rights activist, entered the scene. A ransom was arranged through his good offices and paid sometime in late May. As is usual with such arrangements, the source of the funds, its final recipients and suchlike are unclear. Somalia’s transitional federal government, which is against ransom payments, might even have (which may be between $2 million to $4 million) in Mogadishu on May 25th. Eventually though, the pirates released the ship and its crew.

But the drama didn’t end there. Pirates attacked it again after it was released, and a Pakistani naval ship, Babur, which happened to be in the vicinity as part of the international coalition task force (CTF-151) came to its assistance and chased the pirates away. The Pakistani initiatives received well-deserved applause all around, including in the Indian media. After all, Pakistani individuals and the Pakistani navy had helped secure the return of Indian sailors when the Indian government, on the face of it, didn’t. Indeed, the episode turns a little bizarre thereafter. MV Suez‘s crew claims they called an Indian naval ship, the Godavari, for assistance, but it didn’t respond. According to the Indian Navy, Godavari diverted course from the two ships it was escorting and tried to contact the Suez, failed, and returned to its original course. The Pakistani authorities now charge that INS Godavari “hampered humanitarian operations”, violated international codes of conduct and brushed against PNS Babur. Whoa!

Now it is extremely unlikely that the Godavari‘s captain would deliberately engage in such behaviour. It won’t be difficult to establish facts of the case, as video footage is likely to be available. The Pakistani navy is under a cloud at this moment, and the officers of PNS Babar might have resented the presence—of all ships, an Indian one—at their moment of glory. Interestingly, MV Suez’s captain suggested that even PNS Babar was attacked by pirates, which was denied by the Pakistani navy chief.

The media coverage does not emphasise the reality that the high seas are global commons. The world’s navies on anti-piracy operations are securing the world’s shipping, providing international public goods. This is, of course, interpreted selectively, but by and large, it is not uncommon for one country’s naval ship to assist ships of other countries. In any case, international shipping is a truly international enterprise: with owners, flags, crews and cargos belonging to different countries. One’s own security lies in everyone’s security. So it is that as of November 2010, more than 1037 foreign-flagged ships benefited from the Indian Navy’s protection, compared to only 144 Indian-flagged ones. You can be sure that most of those ships, Indian or foreign, had some crew members who were Indian nationals.

The Indian government was in a bind because it could neither pay out ransoms itself nor condone the payment of ransom by others. It therefore couldn’t satisfy the relatives of the hostages. This is understandable. What is not understandable, and certainly not excusable, is its inability to manage the hostage crisis competently. The Ministry of External Affairs explained the limits of its mandate, passing the buck to the Director General of Shipping. The Ministry of Shipping had little to offer. The Ministry of Overseas Indian Affairs made promises it was unlikely to be able to keep. The lack of purposefulness is palpable even if the Indian Navy continues to discharge its duties admirably.

The Cabinet Committee on Security must create a Maritime Security Management Task Force, headed by a serving or retired officer with expertise in maritime security and intelligence. Reporting to the National Security Advisor, it must have senior officers from the ministries of external affairs, defence, shipping, commerce, the cabinet secretariat, in addition to the three armed services. The buck on piracy matters should stop there.

(This article first appeared in the Indian National interest blog spot – The Acron, on June 18, 2011)
why do wife cheat online how to cheat on husband
abortion pill story price of abortion pill statistics of abortion
spy cell phone tracking how to spy on cell phone spy text messages
symptoms of an std in women click std on tongue pictures
mens symptoms of chlamydia where to get std test free std
did my husband cheat blog.artistamobile.com is it my fault my husband cheated
cheat on my boyfriend click should i cheat on my boyfriend
my husband cheated with a man floridafriendlyplants.com what makes married men cheat
will my husband cheat again robertsuk.com will my husband cheat again
mature sex stories solveit.openjive.com erotic stories sex stories
kr vijaya sex stories open teen sex stories
adult sex stories astrobix.com free sodomy sex stories
kristens adult stories free audio sex stories hindi erotic sex stories
sex stories in hindi scottdangelo.com written adult stories with animals and humans having sex
text message spy apps prashanthiblog.com find apps for android
reasons wives cheat on their husbands i dreamed my wife cheated on me how do i know if my wife has cheated
walgreen printable coupon walgreens pharmacy coupons 2015 walgreens coupons online
discount pharmacy card dotnetblogengine.net coupons viagra
dapoxetine mgdking.com tadalafil 60mg
priligy 90mg mostefaiamine.com diflucan
celecoxib 200mg relotrans.com thyroxine 50mcg
propecia 1mg ilkpirlantam.com sildenafil citrate 200mg
dapoxetine 60mg f6finserve.com viagra 25mg
prescription drugs coupons markthrice.com free discount prescription card
how much does it cost to have an abortion abortion pill where can i get the abortion pill
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
acheter viagra en france livraison 48h http://acheterviagraenfrance.com/en/france-livraison-48h acheter viagra en france livraison 48h
free prescription discount cards read prescription drug discount cards
free cialis coupon 2016 codesamples.in cialis coupon free
loperamidehydrochloride blog.smartofficecloud.com loperamide eg
etodolac abuse markthrice.com etodolac
levitra spc levitrans levitra original
jasmine trinca link jasmine pilchard-gosnell
jasmine disney go jasmine villegas
risperdal nebenwirkung driverblog.suddath.com risperdal absetzen
buscopan inj site buscopan compositum
transfer prescription coupon datum-digital.com new prescription coupon
coupons websites for groceries alpinipedrengo.com grocery coupon site
coupons and discounts link discount coupon
vytorin controversy community.vitechcorp.com vytorin
norfloxacin uses modelus.com norfloxacin uses 400mg
seroquel 25 seroquel xr seroquel compendium
endep 10 weight gain endep medication for pain relief endep 10mg
kamagra kamagra brez recepta kamagra brez recepta
strattera coupon card angkortaxidriver.com strattera coupon card
viagra wiki website-knowledge.com viagra online
cialis online coupon bangzontheweb.com free cialis samples coupon
how does an abortion pill work achrom.be how to have an abortion pill
coupons for cialis selba.ca lilly cialis coupons
acetazolamide migraine acetazolamide sivuvaikutukset acetazolamide symptoms
cialis discounts coupons cialis.com coupon cialis discount coupons online
duphaston tablete kako se piju duphaston cijena bez recepta duphaston
vermox cena vermox cena vermox spc
abortions facts airascatering.com pill abortion
abortion pill pros and cons rubinetteriemariani.it abortion pill clinics in md
cialis coupon lilly prescription coupons cialis 2015 coupon
vermox prospect vermox prospect vermox pret
printable coupons for cialis 2015 cialis coupon coupons for prescriptions
addyi suomi addyi fda addyi review
coupons for cialis printable cialis coupons printable prescription transfer coupon
prescription drug coupons cialis.com coupons prescription coupon
abortion pill clinics in md ouralfreton.co.uk abortion pill questions
how much do abortion pill cost ameracorporation.com where to get an abortion pill
metoprololsuccinat hexal 50 mg metoprololsuccinat bivirkninger metoprolol pro medicin
coupon prescription cialis online coupon cialis coupons printable
alternatives to abortion pill alessiariflesso.com abortion pill cons
abortion pill laws price of abortion pill anti abortion facts
teenage abortion pill abortion pill cost different types of abortion pill
priligy resepti community.vitechcorp.com priligy hinta
abortion pill debate abortion pill prices misoprostol abortion
cialis discount coupon lilly cialis coupons discount prescriptions coupons
naltrexone withdrawal symptoms onlineseoanalyzer.com neltrexon
revia medication reviews site naltrexone for alcohol abuse
naltrexone injection for opiate addiction link revia dosage