Author : Nitin Rai

Why does China need an aircraft carrier?

China’s new aircraft carrier should surprise only those who were not looking—it has been China’s largest open secret for several years now. It has been apparent, literally,—thanks to Google Earth—, that the partially-completed Soviet-era vessel that China’s Chong Lot Travel Agency purchased for $20m in the late-1990s, complete with designs, was not really going to be used as a floating casino and amusement park. There have been other signs, including facilities and training programmes for naval personnel and aviators, that suggested China intended to operate aircraft carriers. As early as 1987, General Liu Huaqing, the recently deceased father of the modern PLA Navy, said that “Without an aircraft carrier, I will die with my eyelids open; the Chinese Navy needs to build an aircraft carrier.”

So both stated intentions and signs on the ground indicated that an aircraft carrier was on the cards. The only question was why, for the PLA Navy’s strategy over the last two decades has been to counter the United States’ formidable surface fleet through the development of its own submarine force. This strategy—of using submarines to neutralise the power of aircraft carriers and warships—was pioneered by the Soviet Union’s Admiral Sergey Gorshkov. In a remarkable demonstration of irony or its deficiency, the Soviets named one of their aircraft carriers after him, the same that India since purchased and is awaiting delivery of.

If aircraft carriers are a platform for a country to project hard power far beyond its shores, submarines are an effective way deny to them space. China had around 65 operational submarines last year. In 2007, one of them slipped past an array of ships and aircraft into an area in the Pacific Ocean where the US Navy’s aircraft carrier strike group was conducting training exercises. That incident was a stark reminder of the vulnerability of aircraft carriers to the Gorshkov strategy. It was also a signal of the changed maritime balance in the Western Pacific ocean.

The utility of aircraft carriers as a device to project power on the littoral is also undermined by anti-ship missiles. Chinese-made anti-ship missiles or their variants are deployed, among others, by North Korea, Myanmar, Iran, Bangladesh and possibly Pakistan. To the extent that their range, capability and proliferation grows, aircraft carriers become less useful in their traditional roles of power projection.

In other words, aircraft carriers will need to increasingly stay away from hostile shores, limiting their effectiveness. The benefits of deploying an aircraft carrier is likely to diminish over time, even if the costs stay the same. An aircraft carrier may pack a bigger punch, but is also more vulnerable in itself, costlier to protect and causes a greater strategic setback if damaged or destroyed. After doing so much to neutralise the strategic utility of aircraft carriers why does China want to deploy them? Of course, there is prestige. Another reason is to do with the balance of power within the Chinese Community Party and the People’s Liberation Army, where pro-PLA Navy factions might have strengthened in recent years. That said, it is difficult to conclude if the navy’s growing political clout is the cause or the effect of the geopolitical churn in East Asia. Beyond these explanations there are three broad reasons why China might want to use aircraft carriers for.

The first is Taiwan. The very name proposed for the new carrier, Shi Lang, suggests Taiwan as its intended target. Shi Lang, a Manchu Qing dynasty general, conquered and annexed Taiwan into the Chinese empire in 1683, defeating the Qing dynasty elite who had fled to that island. Lan Ning-Li, a retired Taiwanese admiral notes that “the carrier would be in a position to move in areas surrounding southern and eastern Taiwan…(making it) vulnerable to enemy attacks at sea from both front and rear.” With nuclear weapons and submarines deterring the United States, an aircraft carrier will add to China’s military capabilities in a possible invasion of Taiwan. The PLA’s statement that “even after China owns an aircraft carrier, it is impossible for China to send the carrier into the territories of other countries” does not rule out use against Taiwan, which according to Beijing is part of China, thanks to the original Shi Lang.

Second, an aircraft carrier can be used as a vehicle for China to enforce its territorial claims over the Yellow, East and South China seas. If so, Shi Lang will be replacing fishing trawlers that have engaged in decidedly unfishermanly activities such as carrying surveillance equipment, ramming Japanese patrol boats, entangling with cables connected to Vietnamese exploration vessels and squatting over unpopulated islands. These presumably non-state actors currently perform the function of tripwires, creating incidents that trigger Beijing to assert its maritime claims. Introducing aircraft carriers into this game is dangerous, but the threat to do so could deter the US Navy from entering the fray in support of its allies.

Finally, China’s interests are global. It is likely to want to set up expeditionary forces to operate in distant theatres to pursue those interests. This is normal. However, like “peaceful rise”, a “defensive aircraft carrier” is a layer of sugar coating applied to make the indigestible just a little more palatable.

This is the unedited draft of my column in the Business Standard today.
vacuum abortion anti abortion arguments why have an abortion
dilation and curettage recovery average cost of abortion about abortion
all women cheat percent of women that cheat
i want to cheat on my boyfriend click my boyfriend cheated on me with my best friend
why cheat on your wife wives who want to cheat
boyfriend cheated on me will my wife cheat again
women who cheat on husbands cheaters caught
kristens adult stories free audio sex stories hindi erotic sex stories
how to find spy app on android read android phone spyware
walgreens photo coupons code free grocery coupons
walgreens coupon codes for photos discount prescription cards
abortions per year second trimester abortion abortion facts
rx discount pharmacy walgreens online coupons 2015
renova 0.05% link acyclovir 400mg
gabapentin 600mg acyclovir 800mg
coupon for free viagra site drug discount coupons
can i take diovan with mucinex click can i take diovan with mucinex
cialis dose vs viagra cialis dosage for bph cialis dosage for 170 pounds
best ed treatment for diabetes read symptoms and treatment of diabetes
cheap online viagra effects of viagra buy viagra internet
viagra szedése viagra 100mg viagra 100mg
cialis gel cialis prodaja cialis forum
lamisil cream boots lamisil cream cvs
augmentin eureka augmentin et alcool
levitra spc levitrans levitra original
cheap cialis cheap cialis cialis walgreen coupon
voltaren dolo voltaren dolo voltaren dispers
buscopan inj buscopan compositum
esomeprazole sandoz side effects esomeprazole rbx nexium
discount coupon for cialis open cialis coupon
research paper on abortion against abortion facts facts against abortion
types of abortion go abortion clinics in richmond va
ondansetron orally ondansetron 8mg
endep 10 weight gain endep 25 mg endep 10mg
how much do abortion pill cost chemical abortion pill
amoxicillin endikasyonlar amoxicillin dermani haqqinda amoxicillin 500 mg
nortriptylin wirkung nortriptylin nebenwirkungen nortriptylin adhs
abortion pill cost side effects of abortion pill free abortion pill
print free coupons coupons viagra
cialis online coupon coupons for cialis free cialis samples coupon
vermox vermox
prescription drug coupons coupon cialis printable coupons for cialis
viagra online viagra online viagra prodej
metoprololsuccinat orion 50 mg metoprolol pro medicin metoprololsuccinat bivirkninger
cialis discounts coupons prescription transfer coupon cialis discount coupons online
abortion pill centers partial birth abortion average cost of an abortion pill
priligy keskustelu priligy
costs of abortion pill price of abortion pill information about abortion pill
vermox tablete nuspojave vermox
amoxicillin al 1000 amoxicillin nedir
discount coupons for prescriptions cialis coupon free cialis coupons online
amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat amoxicilline
abortion pill free abortion pill
voltaren nedir voltaren nedir voltaren ampul
duphaston tablete kako se piju duphaston 10 mg
acetazolamide spc acetazolamide cerebral edema acetazolamide migraine
types of abortion pill price of an abortion pill
how much do abortion pill cost natural abortion pill methods anti abortion pill
lamisil lamisil para que sirve lamisil cream
coupon discount codes coupons online for free grocery coupon sites
best coupons websites andreinfo online coupons codes
amoxicillin al 1000 amoxicillin-rnp
lamisil pomada lamisil crema precio lamisil pomada
amoxicilline amoxicillin amoxicillin antibiyotik fiyat
prescription drugs coupon cialis coupon lilly cialis discount coupons online
naltrexone dosage for alcoholism what is naltrexone 50mg
ldn and ulcerative colitis site vivitrol
low dose naltrexone side effects multiple sclerosis naltrexone fda approval
vivitrol canada naltrexone multiple sclerosis
low dose naloxone where to buy low dose naltrexone alcohol blocker
naltrexone contraindications click revia naltrexone

Back To Top