• :
  • :

                                                                          
       

HOW STABLE IS SOUTH ASIA 14 YEARS AFTER POKHRAN II?



Author : C.Uday Bhaskar


On May 11, 1998, India carried out a nuclear test and became a de facto nuclear weapon power. A few weeks later, Pakistan followed suit and demonstrated its own nuclear weapon capability. The covert nuclear weapon status of the South Asian region had become unambiguous. India had crossed the nuclear Rubicon after it had first signalled its technological ability to do so in May 1974 — with what was described as a Peaceful Nuclear Explosion (PNE).

Today, it is moot if the South Asian region has become more or less secure and stable as far as its strategic profile is concerned. The fact that Pakistan tested its Hatf III ballistic missile on the eve of the 14th anniversary of India’s Pokhran II nuclear tests is a poignant reminder of the dynamic and opaque nature of the regional WMD environment.

It may be recalled that on April 19, India tested its 5,000 km Agni V missile, thereby enhancing its deterrent capability — and the commitment to a NFU (No First Use) doctrine. The latter is predicated on absorbing a nuclear attack — should the exigency arise due to deterrence failure — but the Indian response would be ‘massive’ and overwhelming.

However, the regional framework is not limited to the India-Pakistan dyad and includes China — which is part of the extended southern Asian grid. Sino-Pak WMD cooperation is abiding and has both muddied and rendered more complex the challenge for India. The response matrix for India is to address two visible tracks — the Sino-Indian dyad and the Indo-Pak one — against the context of a subterranean Sino-Pak axis and define sufficiency in the most appropriate and affordable manner.

India’s status quo character is accepted by its principal interlocutor — China — and there does not appear to be any heightened anxiety about each other’s WMD capability, or that either side would resort to WMD brinkmanship to redress contentious issues such as the long standing territorial and border dispute. India has not sought equivalence with China in the WMD domain and is currently defining its own perch of sufficiency and mutuality. But the same cannot be said about how the Pakistani WMD arsenal is perceived and Rawalpindi’s own comprehension of its strategic capabilities. Pakistan’s deep and congenital insecurity apropos India goes back to October 1947 and the loss of East Pakistan in the 1971 war for Bangladesh is embedded in the Pakistani military psyche. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, who became the PM after the war, provided the political support for the Pakistani ‘bomb’ and A.Q. Khan was one of his protégés who provided the purloined technical support.

Pakistan, it was presumed, needed the nuclear weapon to assuage its anxiety and insecurity vis-à-vis India and a very promising start was made in February 1999 when India and Pakistan signed the Lahore Accord to lay the foundation for WMD stability. PMs Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Nawaz Sharif seemed to exude the kind of maturity and restraint that the world welcomed.

Alas, this proved to be misplaced and was aborted in the May 1999 Kargil War. The world watched with bated breath as Pakistan under the flamboyant and feckless General Musharraf sought to alter a territorial issue by alluding to WMD capability. The nightmare of revisionism by taking recourse to nuclear capability had become a reality. In the interregnum from May 1998, the world has gone through the enormity of 9/11 and the emergence of the non-state entity who is cognisant of the WMD capability; the A.Q. Khan nuclear Wal-mart iceberg which has been adroitly masked; anxiety about the physical safety of the Pakistani arsenal; radicalisation of elements within the Pakistani military and some disturbing linkages between North East and South Asia as regards WMD proliferation.

Cruise missiles and short-range ballistic missiles have become very visible in the inventory of both India and Pakistan and their deterrence stability index is suspect. Legitimate claims by the Indian scientists about the technical accomplishment acquired — as for instance in the case of the Agni V — have been imbued by the external interlocutor with strategic import that is both invalid and dangerous. Nationalist rhetoric has raced ahead of a jagged reality — and China has added its bit most recently in April.

There is limited dialogue between India and Pakistan at the official level about each other’s WMD capabilities and intent — and what little exists is in the Track II domain. WMD stability is predicated on proven techno-strategic capability, objective transparency and deft signalling. During the Cold War, the U.S. and the former USSR had a stable of professionals and experts who were marinated in arms control minutiae. Yes, there was an element of good fortune in the manner that an actual nuclear exchange or accident was averted during the menacing Cold War decades but the professionals laid a sturdy foundation.

Southern Asia will need more than luck to manage its muddied and opaque WMD eco-system. The 14th anniversary of the May 1998 nuclear test is an opportune moment to embark on this arduous task.

(This article first appeared in Reuters Blogon May 10, 2012.)
urine test for chlamydia can you get chlamydia in your mouth gonorrhea treatment
spy cell phone tracking mobile spyware software spy text messages
my husband and i both cheated damske.com i cheated on my husband and never told him
my husband cheated with a man floridafriendlyplants.com what makes married men cheat
i had a dream my girlfriend cheated on me wrightcontractingsi.com my girlfriend wants me to cheat on her
why do men cheat on their wife link dating for married men
how many people cheat click why wife cheated
boyfriend cheated on me most women cheat will my wife cheat again
why do wifes cheat mapbiquity.com signs of a cheater
statistics about abortion terminating a pregnancy surgical aspiration abortion
i dream my husband cheated on me dogancoruh.com why men have affairs
coupons rite aid site pharmacy coupons 2015
why people cheat in marriage blog.gobiztech.com what makes people cheat
discount card for prescription drugs open viagra coupon pfizer
doxycycline sildenafil citrate 50mg valacyclovir 1g
viagra manufacturer coupon 2016 drug discount coupons viagra trial coupon
free viagra coupon go discount prescriptions coupons
how much does it cost to have an abortion abortion pill where can i get the abortion pill
lisinopril and eye pain lisinopriland.net lisinopril and eye pain
cialis medicament prix cialis medicament prix cialis medicament prix
cialis coupons online cialis discount coupons discount card for prescription drugs
cialis coupons 2015 click cialis sample coupon
cialis 5mg cialis generika cialis nebenwirkungen
lamisil cream boots bistromc.org lamisil cream cvs
augmentin eureka read augmentin et alcool
buscopan floridafriendlyplants.com buscopan ampula
sildenafil citrate chemical name blog.cardsapp.com sildenafil citrate structural formula
naproxen 500 naproxen saft naproxen
gino-canesten creme go gino-canesten corrimento rosado
cyklokapron blog.rewardsrunner.com cyklokapron dosering
microlite pill when to start sigridw.com microlite spc
endep 10 weight gain gerarprieto.com endep 10mg
voltaren krem nedir voltaren gel voltaren krem fiyat
having an abortion natural abortion pill price of an abortion pill
when is it too late to get an abortion pill abortion pill process against abortion pill
strattera coupon card buy strattera without prescription strattera coupon card
abortion pill costs pill abortion methods of abortion pill
free coupon sites printable free discount codes free online coupon
naltrexone effectiveness http://naltrexonealcoholismmedication.com/ naltrexone adverse effects
duphaston i ovulacija duphaston duphaston tablete za odgodu menstruacije
duphaston tablete kako se piju duphaston 10 mg duphaston
abortions facts airascatering.com pill abortion
nootropil 800 g house.raupes.net nootropil cena
printable coupons for cialis 2015 cialis coupon coupons for prescriptions
coupons for cialis coupon for prescriptions cialis coupon codes
how much do abortion pill cost abortion pill quotes where to get an abortion pill
metoprololsuccinat hexal 50 mg metoprololsuccinat bivirkninger metoprolol pro medicin
discount coupons for prescriptions agrisol.com.ar coupons for prescription medications
abortion pill laws price of abortion pill abortion pill questions
second trimester abortion how much does abortion pill cost definition of abortion pill
voltaren nedir voltaren ampul voltaren ampul
home abortion pill methods when can you get an abortion pill should abortion pill be legal
cialis 20 mg cialis pris cialis kopiprodukter
types of abortion pill abcomke.sk price of an abortion pill
lamisil lamisil para que sirve lamisil cream
abortion pill centers amazonschools.com buy abortion pill
cytotec abortion pathakwavecurecenter.com abortion pill articles
amoxicillin 1000 mg amoxicillin amoxicillin al 1000
amoxicillin al 1000 amoxicillin 500 mg amoxicillin-rnp
health risks of abortion abortion pill nyc price of an abortion
lilly coupons for cialis cialis sample coupon prescription card discount
will naltrexone show on a drug test click vivitrol alcohol treatment