• :
  • :

                                                                          
       

INDIA AND SOUTH ASIA: STATES NEED TO BE STAKEHOLDERS



Author : C.Uday Bhaskar


India’s external environment and the related foreign policy challenges, with a special focus on the South Asian neighbourhood, were usefully illuminated in the course of this week by Foreign Minister S.M. Krishna and National Security Adviser Shivshankar Menon.

This was also a period when the domestic political focus was on state elections -- with the Uttar Pradesh results and the contest between the Samajwadi Party heir Akhilesh Yadav and Gandhi family scion Rahul Gandhi receiving the greatest attention.

Yet, paradoxically, there is an inherent linkage in the success and credibility of India’s regional foreign policy with the degree to which the proximate states become stakeholders in such an endeavor. In short, Indian foreign (and security) policy, particularly the immediate South Asian neighbourhood policy – which, till recently, was the sole purview of the Union Government in New Delhi -- will have to be rewired, so as to accommodate and benefit from inputs that the state capitals provide. The corollary is that at a time when the “uneasy coalition” is likely to be the prominent feature of Indian domestic politics and the two major national parties (the Congress and the Bharatiya Janata Party, or BJP) are dependent on regional leaders – the evolution and conduct of successful South Asian foreign policy by New Delhi will require the relevant state capitals to acquire appropriate neighbourhood interest and expertise.

Speaking on ‘India’s External Environment and Current Foreign Policy Challenges’ at Singapore’s Institute of South Asian Studies on March 9, Foreign Minister Krishna asserted: “The biggest development over the past two decades in our continent has been the evolution of the process of Asian re-integration.” This is almost like a report card of the ruling United Progressive Alliance (UPA) since it came to office in 2004 and here the emphasis is on the Manmohan Singh vision of regional economic integration that would trump adversarial or prickly political relationships. Minister Krishna dwelt on how India has been implementing a policy of asymmetric engagement in providing greater market access to its neighbours, so as to enable integration in a mutually beneficial manner. And he added for good measure that: “This is one of the most significant challenges facing our foreign policy today.”

Reiterating this theme, the NSA Shivshankar Menon spoke on ‘Transforming South Asia’ at the Third Asian Relations Conference organised by the Indian Council for World Affairs (ICWA) and the AAS in New Delhi and drew attention to the imbalance between the political and economic linkages in the South Asian region. Exhorting the experts drawn from all the South Asian nations to apply their minds to this challenge, Menon encouraged them to: “Start considering cooperative security frameworks and architectures for this sub-region, and what conditions would be necessary to make them successful. There are a host of issues such as terrorism, maritime security and cyber security which require cooperative solutions and which bear consideration by groups like yours. In the meantime, we should also move forward much more rapidly on connectivity, including energy and grid connectivity, tourism, people-to-people, trade and economic links that can make such a major contribution to improving our future.”

However, as Delhi knows from recent experience, Prime Minister Singh’s September 2011 visit to Dhaka, that should have been a major achievement of India’s bilateral relations, went off the tracks thanks to the obstructionist stance adopted by the newly-elected Chief Minister of West Bengal, Mamta Banerjee. It is not the intention of this comment to dwell on the validity of the Kolkata position but to make a case for much greater and sustained consultation between Delhi and the concerned state capitals when it comes to advancing such bilateral relations.

The West Bengal-Bangladesh linkage offers a very useful case study that encompasses all the aspects touched upon by Minister Krishna and NSA Menon. Developing better connectivity – road, rail and maritime, including the rivers – will dramatically enhance the prosperity and human security indicators for the entire region that extends to the Indian Northeast and Myanmar.

However, this cannot happen in the absence of a comprehensive appreciation in both Delhi and Kolkata of the linkages between the domains – trade, economy, environment, security – and, finally, better politics. Reviving the Kolkata-Dhaka-Yangon transport links, for instance, would in a way resurrect the rhythms of the pre-1947 era, but for this to be realised, Kolkata must be a willing stakeholder in this vision.

In much the same manner, both Uttar Pradesh and Bihar are relevant states in relation to Nepal and Bhutan – whether the issue is connectivity or harnessing hydro power potential. But unless Lucknow and Patna become partners with Delhi in this endeavor, these foreign policy objectives are unlikely to be realised.

Thus what merits attention is the need for individual states to acquire this degree of awareness about foreign policy issues – both in their legislatures and among their officials. Over the last decade and more, both when the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) was in power and more recently with the UPA at the helm -- the Ministry of External Affairs has mooted a proposal to post Indian Foreign Service (IFS) officers in individual states to provide state capitals this expertise. However, this has not moved meaningfully. The issue needs to be revived and state legislatures should be encouraged to deliberate over foreign policy issues in a regular manner.

The recent success of the Samajwadi Party in the Uttar Pradesh elections and the nomination of Akhilesh Yadav as the Chief Minister of India’s most populous state offers a rare opportunity.

While shaking off the “goonda-raj” perception is no doubt the top priority for the new government to be formed in Lucknow, demonstrating an interest in foreign policy-related issues by the new Chief Minister could send a very strong signal – all the way to Kolkata and beyond.

(Commodore [Retd] C. Uday Bhaskar is one of India’s foremost strategic analysts. He can be contacted at cudayb@gmail.com. This article first appeared in South Asia Monitor on March 12, 2012)
wives who cheat on husbands why do wifes cheat wife who cheated
abortion pill story dilatation and curettage statistics of abortion
urine test for chlamydia stds and symptoms gonorrhea treatment
first signs of hiv infection how hiv is transmitted aids and hiv symptoms
best spyware for android cell phones read android spy camera
i had a dream i cheated on my boyfriend my boyfriend thinks i cheated on him i have cheated on my boyfriend
married men who have affairs developersalley.com women cheat because
how many people cheat click why wife cheated
kristens adult stories free audio sex stories hindi erotic sex stories
text message spy apps prashanthiblog.com find apps for android
drugs coupons photo coupon codes walgreens photo promo code
free pharmacy card acup.fr prescription drugs discount card
sildenafil citrate 130mg policereference.co.uk synthroid 25mcg
viagra free sample coupons open free discount prescription cards
free viagra coupon floridafriendlyplants.com discount prescriptions coupons
can i take celebrex if i have a sulfa allergy can i take celebrex if i have a sulfa allergy can i take celebrex if i have a sulfa allergy
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
cialis dosage information diabetes effect on male sexuality cialis for women dosage
cialis low price cialis prescription discount card coupons for cialis
free prescription discount cards read prescription drug discount cards
cialis coupons 2015 open cialis sample coupon
free coupon for cialis drug coupon card prescription coupons
cialis discount coupons prostudiousa.com cialis discount coupons
cialis discount coupon prescription card discount drug coupon card
arava read arava
sildenafil citrate chemical name blog.cardsapp.com sildenafil citrate structural formula
gino-canesten creme read gino-canesten corrimento rosado
cyklokapron blog.rewardsrunner.com cyklokapron dosering
microlite pill when to start sigridw.com microlite spc
trental online buy go trental cijena
transfer prescription coupon site cialis free sample coupons
amoxicillin 1000 mg amoxicilline amoxicillin
kamagra kamagra gel kamagra brez recepta
loette 21 comprimidos mattnichols.co.uk loette diario
cialis coupon lilly coupons for cialis 2016 discount coupon for cialis
vermox vermox vermox sirup
abortion pill costs abortions cost methods of abortion pill
coupons for cialis selba.ca lilly cialis coupons
non surgical abortion pill albayraq-uae.com abortion pill complications
abortion pill centers partial birth abortion average cost of an abortion pill
abortion pill process medical abortion pill abortion pill quotes
cost of medical abortion early abortion pill options early abortion pill options
facts on abortion pill lupidellamajella.it cost of abortion pill
cialis tadalafil cialis pris cialis wiki
second trimester abortion how much does abortion pill cost definition of abortion pill
clomid clomid proviron pct clomid testosterone
voltaren nedir voltaren ampul voltaren ampul
cialis 100 mg cialis 5 mg cialis 20
information on abortion pill third trimester abortion pill abortion clinics in houston tx
how to get an abortion pill arborawning.com abortion pill facts
cialis sample coupon transfer prescription coupon cialis sample coupon
flagyl suspension news.hostnetindia.com flagyl 500 mg
cialis discount coupons online automatedwireless.com discount prescription coupons
cialis discount coupon free cialis coupon 2016 discount prescriptions coupons
naltrexone injection cost read naltrexone 50 mg
does vivitrol block alcohol naltrexone overdose heroin detox
will naltrexone show on a drug test click vivitrol alcohol treatment