MALDIVES CRISIS TESTS INDIA’S REGIONAL PROFILE
Author : C.Uday Bhaskar
The on-going political crisis in the
small Indian Ocean island nation of Maldives which erupted on February 7
(Tuesday) and led to the ouster of former President Mohamed Nasheed and
the swearing in of the Vice President Mohammed Waheed Hassan Manik is
proving to be a complex challenge to India’s regional profile in the
extended South Asian region.
Maldives which comprises about 1200 scattered islands in the Indian
Ocean is located in the Lacadive Sea and is about 400 kilometres
south-west of India. It was initially a Dutch protectorate in the 17th
century and later became a British island territory and finally achieved
independence in 1965. Political stability was established by former
President Maumoon Abdul Gayoom who ruled for three decades – in a firm
and autocratic manner - and he was finally unseated in 2008 by President
Nasheed through the first free and fair democratic elections.
Acclaimed as liberal democrat who sought to bring about many rapid
changes in the socio-religious-political structure of a 100 percent
Islamic nation of about 400,000 citizens, it is evident that Mr.
Nasheed created more opponents than he had imagined in the last three
years. The current situation has gone through a turbulent five days and
this has added to India’s discomfiture. It was initially announced that
in the face of growing opposition and protests to his rule, Mr.
Nasheed had decided to hand over power to his Vice President Waheed – as
per the Constitution (Maldives has opted for a US modelled executive
Presidential form of governance ). A day later Mr. Nasheed claimed
that he was forced to resign – at gun-point – and hence this was a
‘coup’. In the intervening period, Delhi had already welcomed the
transition to a new President and violent clashes broke out between the
Nasheed supporters and his opponents.
In the last two days Delhi has dispatched a special envoy to visit the
island state and assuage the growing tension. Concurrently the UN and
the USA have also sent their representatives with UK as the head of the
Commonwealth also conducting an investigation into the ouster of
President Nasheed. Thus India’s primacy in the region is now being
diluted and this is one of the many challenges that Delhi will have to
The prevailing political situation in Male is tense with Mr. Nasheed
calling for fresh elections while an interim government headed by the
Speaker of the Majlis is in place. However the new President Waheed
maintains that he is the man in charge now – as per the Constitution –
and that he would seek to form a national government with the help of
all the main political parties. In this regard, the role of the former
President Gayoom is critical and the latter – who is no ally of Mr.
Nasheed has welcomed the new Waheed government and denied that he had
any role in the Nasheed ouster.
What is being contested, political power apart - is the kind of
socio-religious-political model that would be adopted by a nation that
is 100 percent Islamic in the transition to participative democratic
rule. Here the small demography of Maldives (400,000) has some
instructive lessons for other parts of the world that are similarly
poised – from the Arab Spring to parts of South and South-East Asia.
Dependent on tourism and fishing in the main, Maldives is a relatively
affluent South Asian nation and has a GDP of US $ 2 billion and a per
capita of about $ 6,000 per annum.
The younger generation in Maldives – concentrated mainly in the capital
Male and Addu (where the SAARC Summit was held in November 2011) are
yearning for change and relate to the rhythms of modernity and the new
‘networked’ global community. However the conservative religious
elements in Maldives who have been influenced by the events before and
after 9/11 and the spread of Islamic radicalism as derived from the
extreme Sunni-Wahabi-Salafist represent the opposition to the Nasheed
vision for Maldives.
The conservative Islamist faction in Maldives – which had been trained
in seminaries in Pakistan and drew inspiration from the ideology of both
the al-Qaeda and the Saudi supported version of political Islam shared a
plank with the anti-Gayoom movement in the 1990’s and in many ways this
was the Faustian bargain that Mr. Nasheed’s MDP (Maldivian Democratic
Party) made with the religious right – the Adaalath party - to form his
government. Concurrently the many changes that the Nasheed regime sought
to introduce were resisted by the old guard – the Gayoom protégé who
had enjoyed unfettered power for 30 years.
The trigger for the current turbulence was an attempt by Mr. Nasheed to
impose his will over the judiciary and other organs of a nascent
democracy which in turn were sympathetic to the religious right in
certain cases related to radicalism and terrorism. The next few days
will be fraught with political uncertainty as Male seeks to find its own
political accommodation. The presence of the UN and the US in the
island nation may enable India to contribute to the speedy resolution of
a complex regional issue – but its implications are significant.
The Maldives has a very strategic geographical location in the Indian
Ocean and a stable, liberal democratic dispensation with strong ties to
Delhi will be in India’s abiding interest. China and Pakistan have their
own relevance in the calculus of Maldives and the exigency India does
not need is a politically empowered and radicalised Islamic entity that
may nurture ideologies and groups that are inimical to Indian interests.
The last time this happened was in Afghanistan and India had to go
through the ignominy of December 1999 – and the Kandahar hijacking
The Indian neighbourhood is going through a turbulent and contested
transition to democracy - be it Nepal, Bangladesh and now Maldives.
Delhi must not be an over-bearing and insensitive big brother in the
region – but the run-up to the Nasheed ouster and why Indian diplomats
were unable to either anticipate or pre-empt the current impasse merits
detailed review by the political apex in Delhi. Could India have been
more astutely pro-active and helped avoid the Maldives muddle?
(This article first appeared in South Asia Monitoron February 12, 2012)